1. Personal Injury Law Firm In NY – NYC Case Background & Initial Concerns
The client met the complainant through a random chat application and communicated for about a month.
Without warning, the complainant filed a police report claiming the client had transmitted a virus classified as an STI an allegation that, if true, could constitute Assault in the Third Degree (NY PL §120.00).
A Personal Injury Law Firm In NY was contacted immediately to prevent the accusation from escalating.
Allegation Overview & Legal Context
Under NY law, “physical injury” may include:
- Minor abrasions
- Illness or infection
- Loss of physical function
- Medically recognized impairment
- Disease transmission
Because the complainant claimed an STI-related physical injury, police treated the accusation seriously at the initial stage.
Possible Criminal Classifications
Offense | Statute | Penalty |
Assault in the Third Degree | PL §120.00 | Up to 1 year jail |
Reckless Assault | PL §120.20 | Misdemeanor |
Assault Causing Serious Physical Injury | PL §120.05 | Felony; up to 7 years |
A Personal Injury Law Firm In NY must evaluate whether intent, causation, and physical injury can be proven with credible evidence.
2. Personal Injury Law Firm In NY – Review of the Client’s Exposure Risk
During consultation, attorneys examined all claims made by the complainant. The client was clear:
- He was not a carrier of any virus
- He never engaged in sexual contact with the complainant
- He believed the accusation stemmed from misunderstanding, speculation, or emotional reaction
The Personal Injury Law Firm In NY analyzed whether the complaint met New York’s legal standards for causation.
Assessment of Injury & Lack of Medical Evidence
The complainant provided no:
- Medical records
- Lab-test results
- Diagnosis from any licensed medical professional
The accusation relied solely on self-diagnosis via internet searches.
The attorney argued that without clinical confirmation, there was no legally recognized physical injury, meaning an essential statutory element of assault was missing.
Lack of Conduct, Intent, and Causation
The firm emphasized:
- No sexual contact occurred
- The alleged virus cannot be transmitted without such contact
- The client possessed medical test results confirming he carried no STI
Thus, intent and causation both mandatory under NY Penal Law were absent.
These findings were summarized in a comprehensive attorney memorandum.
3. Personal Injury Law Firm In NY – Strategic Defense Actions
The attorneys coordinated with NYPD investigators and criminal defense specialists to ensure accurate evaluation and prevent referral to the District Attorney.
Argument of Legal Impossibility
The attorney asserted:
- Transmission was scientifically impossible
- No conduct by the client could satisfy intentional or reckless causation
- Statements from the complainant were inconsistent and unsupported
This directly addressed New York’s statutory definition of physical injury, showing the legal threshold was not met.
Credibility Challenges to the Complaint
The Personal Injury Law Firm In NY highlighted that the complainant had:
- No medical diagnosis
- No proof of infection
- No timeline evidence
- No corroborating witnesses or documents
With such evidentiary gaps, prosecutors could not meet the required burden of proof.
4. Personal Injury Law Firm In NY – Case Outcome & Client Protection
After reviewing all submitted evidence and legal arguments, NYPD closed the case with no charges filed.
The client initially terrified of criminal consequences and reputational damage expressed profound relief.
Why Early Legal Involvement Matters
Accusations involving alleged disease transmission can result in:
- Criminal charges
- Civil personal-injury lawsuits
- Permanent reputational harm
Early intervention by a Personal Injury Law Firm In NY ensures investigators receive accurate facts, preventing unsupported claims from turning into formal prosecution.
How SJKP Can Support You
If you face false injury allegations, claims of disease transmission, or any accusation involving bodily harm, a Personal Injury Law Firm In NY can protect your rights.
SJKP provides:
- Legal analysis of allegations
- Medical and evidentiary review
- Coordination with criminal defense counsel
- Representation in all investigative stages
- Strategic rebuttal of false or unproven accusations
For immediate legal support, contact SJKP for a confidential consultation.
10 Dec, 2025
