High-Value Fraud

Under New York Penal Law, fraud becomes a High-Value Fraud offense when:

• The perpetrator intentionally deceives others for unlawful personal gain.
• The act results in substantial property or financial loss.
• The total damage exceeds $1 million (threshold for class B felony under NYPL §190.80-a).

High-Value Fraud status is activated by exceeding specific monetary thresholds. This classification ensures that major financial swindles face the stringent penalties they warrant under state law.

To establish a High-Value Fraud charge, the prosecution must prove:

The state carries the burden of proving each element beyond a reasonable doubt to secure a conviction for High-Value Fraud. Without clear evidence, a defense can challenge the charge's validity.

Below is a summary comparing standard fraud and High-Value Fraud penalties under New York law:

Sentencing may also increase if the fraud was conducted by an organized group or used sophisticated methods like fake accounting or shell corporations. These enhancements strongly deter massive financial High-Value Fraud schemes.

Cases classified as organized or coordinated fraud “committed by multiple individuals with role division” receive higher penalties. This recognizes the increased danger posed by schemes with a premeditated structure aimed at carrying out High-Value Fraud.

Examples of such organized schemes include:

• Cryptocurrency investment scams using fabricated dashboards.
• Phishing or voice phishing ("vishing") rings impersonating officials.
• Fraudulent apartment rental networks targeting vulnerable individuals.

The collaborative nature of these frauds, a form of High-Value Fraud, is an aggravating factor weighed heavily during sentencing, reflecting the broad impact of these structured criminal operations.

Effective legal defenses against a High-Value Fraud charge involve proving lack of criminal intent or incorrect loss amounts. A focused defense seeks to challenge the core elements of the crime.

• Demonstrating lack of intent or knowledge of the fraudulent scheme.
• Arguing limited participation or a minor role.
• Proving that the loss amount was overstated or not fully realized.
• Presenting substantial voluntary restitution made to victims.
• Highlighting an absence of prior criminal convictions.

Defendants who can reach restitution or settlement with victims, or who voluntarily provide key information, may receive reduced sentences. Such actions can often lead to favorable plea negotiations regarding the alleged High-Value Fraud.

New York courts assess both aggravating and mitigating elements when deciding sentences for High-Value Fraud. The final sentence balances the crime's severity against the defendant's character and post-offense actions.

Aggravating factors:

• Number of victims affected.
• Amount exceeding legal thresholds for High-Value Fraud.
• Recidivism or previous fraud convictions.
• Sophistication of fraud mechanisms (e.g., fake platforms, forged ledgers).

Mitigating factors:

• Defendant’s clean criminal history prior to the current High-Value Fraud charge.
• Early and substantial cooperation with investigators.
• Significant financial restitution to the victims.
• Passive or minor involvement in the execution of the fraud.
•  

The court uses this assessment to determine a just and proportionate sentence, considering all circumstances of the High-Value Fraud.

Anyone accused of High-Value Fraud should avoid making statements to investigators without counsel. Immediate retention of an attorney with expertise in white-collar crime is a foundational step.

Immediate actions may include:

1. Engaging an attorney with white-collar crime expertise immediately.
2. Collecting and preserving all financial records and communication logs relevant to the alleged High-Value Fraud.
3. Assessing potential civil settlement options before indictment to mitigate criminal penalties.

Early involvement of a defense attorney allows for proactive strategy development, invaluable in defending against sophisticated charges of High-Value Fraud.

Victims of High-Value Fraud are strongly advised to gather and organize all evidence relating to the loss and deception. Comprehensive documentation is key to supporting prosecution and civil recovery.

Victims should gather evidence, including:

• Bank transaction records showing transfers to the perpetrators.
• Communication screenshots showing misleading promises.
• Any proof of unauthorized transfers or fake investment documents.

They may also file a complaint with the New York Attorney General’s Office or local District Attorney’s office, depending on the scope of the High-Value Fraud. This helps ensure both criminal justice and financial recovery are pursued.