legal information
We provide a variety of legal knowledge and information, and inform you about legal procedures and response methods in each field.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York
Understanding the disciplinary time limits for government employees in New York is essential for both public employers and employees. These timeframes determine when a disciplinary action must begin, how misconduct is categorized, and whether delays or exceptions apply. This guide outlines the standard deadlines, extension rules, and agency procedures under New York law.
contents
1. Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Legal Overview
New York’s disciplinary system for public employees is based primarily on Civil Service Law §§75 and 76. These laws define which employees are covered, the types of misconduct subject to penalties, and the timelines for initiating action.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Covered Employees
Section 75 applies to non-managerial employees in the competitive class and certain permanent employees in non-competitive or labor classes. Probationary employees and at-will appointees are generally excluded unless otherwise specified by a collective bargaining agreement (CBA).
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Purpose of Time Limits
Time limits exist to protect employees from indefinite exposure to penalties and to encourage prompt accountability by employers. Once the allowable time has passed without action, the employer may forfeit the right to discipline.
2. Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Timeframes by Misconduct Type
The allowable period to initiate disciplinary charges depends on the nature and context of the misconduct.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: General Timeline
Under Civil Service Law §75, disciplinary charges must be served within 18 months from the date the misconduct occurred. This applies to routine offenses such as lateness, minor insubordination, or performance issues.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Felony Exception
An important exception exists: if the alleged misconduct would constitute a crime defined as a felony under New York Penal Law, the 18-month time limit does not apply. In such cases, charges may be brought at any time, but only after the facts become known to the appointing authority.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Summary Table
| Misconduct Type | Time Limit to File Charges | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Minor infractions (e.g., lateness) | 18 months from date of act | Standard under §75 |
| Felony-level misconduct | No statutory time limit | Must be filed promptly upon discovery |
| Misconduct not classified as felony but discovered late | Still subject to 18 months | Unless tolled or extended by rule or contract |
Note: Time begins either at the time of the act or when the employer first had reasonable knowledge, depending on internal policy.
3. Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Tolling and Extension Conditions
Certain conditions may toll (pause) or extend the time period for initiating charges. However, these are not unlimited and must be properly justified.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Circumstances Affecting the Clock
- Pending Criminal Investigation
If an employee is under criminal investigation, agencies may delay action until the outcome is known. However, once the investigation concludes, they must act promptly. - Administrative Leave or Incapacity
Time may be tolled if the employee is medically unable to participate in a hearing or if they are on administrative leave for unrelated reasons. - Union Grievance or Arbitration Pending
Where a collective bargaining agreement controls discipline, the grievance or arbitration process may delay the filing of formal charges.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Limitations of Tolling<
Tolling is not automatic. Agencies must demonstrate that the delay was reasonable and related to valid administrative or legal reasons. Courts have ruled that generic internal delays do not justify bypassing the 18-month rule unless specified.
4. Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Notice and Procedural Requirements
Even when a disciplinary case is timely filed, agencies must adhere to strict procedural rules to maintain validity.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Formal Notice
Agencies must serve the employee with written charges and provide at least eight days’ advance notice before the disciplinary hearing. Failure to provide this notice may invalidate the entire process, even if the charge itself is timely.
Government Employee Disciplinary Time Limit New York: Right to Representation
Employees have the right to be represented by a union or legal counsel in any disciplinary proceeding. This right is protected under state law and collective bargaining agreements, and procedural violations can void disciplinary findings.
The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading or relying on the contents of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm. For advice regarding your specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
