legal information
We provide a variety of legal knowledge and information, and inform you about legal procedures and response methods in each field.
New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Legal Procedure and Evidence Collection Guide
A contested divorce lawsuit in New York is initiated when spouses fail to reach an agreement on key marital issues such as child custody, property division, or spousal support. Unlike uncontested divorce, which relies on mutual consent, a contested divorce proceeds through a full civil litigation process. This guide outlines the step-by-step procedures under New York law and offers practical guidance for securing admissible evidence to strengthen your case.
contents
1. New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Step-by-Step Court Process
To begin a contested divorce in New York, one spouse must file a Summons with Notice or a Summons and Verified Complaint in the Supreme Court of the appropriate county. The plaintiff must state the legal grounds for divorce—such as cruel and inhuman treatment, abandonment for one year, adultery, or irretrievable breakdown of the marriage for at least six months—under Domestic Relations Law §170.
New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Mandatory Preliminary Conference
After filing the Request for Judicial Intervention (RJI), the court schedules a preliminary conference within 45 days. During this meeting, the judge sets deadlines for the exchange of financial documents, deposition dates, and motion practice. Failure to participate may result in sanctions or a judgment against the uncooperative party.
New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Defendant's Response
The defendant has 20 days to file an Answer if served within New York, or 30 days if served outside the state. The Answer typically includes counterclaims and defenses. If no response is filed, the plaintiff may request a default judgment, allowing the court to proceed without the defendant’s input.
New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Discovery and Motion Practice
The discovery phase is crucial for gathering evidence related to income, assets, liabilities, parenting capacity, and any marital misconduct. Both parties are required to submit a Statement of Net Worth, along with tax returns, bank records, and real estate documentation.
Motions can be filed for temporary orders—such as spousal maintenance (temporary alimony), exclusive use of the marital residence, child custody, or restraining orders. Courts consider these motions carefully to preserve the parties’ rights during litigation.
New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Trial and Judgment
If settlement is not reached through negotiation or court-mandated mediation, the case proceeds to trial. Each side presents testimony, submits exhibits, and may call witnesses. The judge evaluates the credibility of evidence and testimony to issue a ruling on all contested matters.
The court’s decision is binding and enforceable upon entry. If either party disagrees with the ruling, they may file a notice of appeal within 30 days after service of the judgment with notice of entry.
New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Final Divorce Decree and Filing
Once the court issues the final judgment of divorce, either party must file the signed decree with the County Clerk. Only after this step is the divorce considered legally finalized. If the parties have children, orders related to custody, visitation, and support must also be included and enforced accordingly.
2. New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Key Evidence Types and Collection Methods
Under New York law, especially in fault-based divorce claims such as adultery or cruel treatment, the burden of proof lies with the petitioner. Proper evidence is essential not only for proving grounds for divorce but also for determining property division, support, and custody.
New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Examples of Admissible Evidence
- Infidelity: Text messages, emails, hotel bills, eyewitness testimony, or private investigator reports may be admitted. Proof must establish both the opportunity and inclination to commit adultery.
- Domestic abuse: Hospital records, police reports, protective orders, and psychological evaluations can demonstrate cruel and inhuman treatment.
- Substance abuse: Testimony, rehab records, and arrest records can support claims of habitual drunkenness or drug abuse.
- Financial misconduct: Hidden asset transfers, forged signatures, or sudden changes in financial accounts may influence equitable distribution rulings.
New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Caution in Evidence Gathering
New York is a one-party consent state for audio recording, but unauthorized surveillance, GPS tracking, or accessing private digital accounts without permission may be illegal and render the evidence inadmissible. Always consult an attorney before collecting potentially sensitive material.
3. New York Contested Divorce Lawsuit: Checklist Before Filing
Before initiating a contested divorce in New York, review the following checklist to ensure readiness for the legal process:
✔ Divorce Readiness Checklist
| Item | Completed |
|---|---|
| Do you have a legal ground for divorce under DRL §170? | ✅ |
| Have you gathered admissible evidence to support your claims? | ✅ |
| Have you completed a Statement of Net Worth? | ✅ |
| Are your children’s interests and proposed custody plan documented? | ✅ |
| Are you aware of temporary orders you may need to request? | ✅ |
The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading or relying on the contents of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm. For advice regarding your specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
