1. Asset Protection in Consignment: Retention of Title and Ownership
The primary objective of a Commercial Consignment is the absolute retention of Title and Ownership by the Consignor until a sale is consummated.
Unlike a traditional sale or return transaction, a consignment does not transfer ownership to the retailer. This distinction is the cornerstone of asset protection, as it theoretically prevents the Consignee creditors from seizing the inventory to satisfy the Consignee debts.
Distinguishing Consignment from Secured Transactions
Under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), many consignments are treated as Security Interests to protect third-party creditors who might be misled by the Consignee possession of the goods. If the agreement is not properly structured and public notice is not provided, a court may deem the transaction a Sale on Credit. This leaves the Consignor as an unsecured creditor in the event of the Consignee bankruptcy. We provide the intellectual rigor necessary to ensure that your agreement is characterized correctly and that your ownership rights remain the highest priority.
2. Consignment Insolvency Risk: Protecting Assets from Consignee Creditors
In most commercial consignments, the mere retention of title is insufficient to protect the Consignor against the Consignee secured lenders.
To ensure that the Consignor can reclaim its goods in an insolvency scenario, the Consignor must perfect its interest by filing a UCC-1 Financing Statement in the appropriate jurisdiction. Without this filing, the inventory is legally considered part of the Consignee estate, available to satisfy the claims of banks and other lienholders.
Perfection of Security Interests and Pmsi Notices
To achieve Super-Priority over a Consignee existing lenders, the Consignor must often provide a Purchase Money Security Interest (PMSI) Notice to those lenders before the consigned goods are delivered. This proactive step prevents the Consignee bank from claiming a superior interest in your inventory. SJKP LLP manages the entire perfection process, from the initial UCC filing to the issuance of statutory notices, ensuring that your inventory does not become a windfall for a Consignee creditors during a liquidation.
3. The Anatomy of a Failed Consignment: Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
Even a well-intentioned consignment relationship can collapse if the parties rely on informal arrangements or fail to adhere to strict operational protocols.
Identifying these failure points during the drafting phase is the only way to prevent a total loss of the underlying assets.
Common catalysts for consignment failure include:
- Informal Oral Modifications: Relying on verbal agreements regarding pricing or return terms that contradict the written contract.
- Failure to Segregate Inventory: Comingling consigned goods with the Consignee general stock, which makes physical recovery nearly impossible during a seizure.
- Missing or Expired UCC Filings: Failing to renew a UCC-1 statement every five years or failing to file in the correct jurisdiction.
- Lack of PMSI Compliance: Delivering goods before notifying the Consignee existing secured creditors.
4. Inventory Risk Management and Asset Protection in Consignment
The effectiveness of a Consignment Agreement depends on the precision of its administrative and financial controls.
A contract that fails to define the Scope of Work for the Consignee or the specific Payment Terms is a primary catalyst for commercial friction.
Definition of Consigned Goods and Inventory Controls
The agreement must include a microscopic description of the Consigned Goods, often utilizing a revolving schedule or manifest. We implement rigorous Inventory Control protocols that require the Consignee to segregate the consigned goods from their general stock. This physical and legal separation is essential for proving ownership during an audit or a sudden warehouse seizure.
Pricing Authority and Minimum Sales Thresholds
A common source of dispute is the Consignee unauthorized discounting of high-value assets. We draft specific Pricing Authority clauses that prevent the Consignee from selling below a Floor Price without the Consignor express written consent. This protects the brand equity and the financial return of the Consignor while providing the Consignee with clear boundaries for negotiation.
5. Risk of Loss and Comprehensive Insurance Mandates
Once the goods leave the Consignor possession, the Risk of Loss must be clearly allocated to the party best positioned to protect the inventory.
While the Consignor retains title, the Consignee typically assumes all risk for theft, damage, or destruction while the goods are in their care, custody, and control.
Insurance and Indemnification Requirements
We mandate that the Consignee maintain a specific level of All-Risk Property Insurance, naming the Consignor as the Loss Payee and Additional Insured. This ensures that if the inventory is destroyed in a fire or lost to theft, the insurance proceeds flow directly to the owner of the goods. Furthermore, robust Indemnification clauses protect the Consignor from third-party claims arising from the Consignee marketing or handling of the products.
6. Payment Structures, Commissions, and Audit Rights
A Consignment Agreement must function as a transparent financial blueprint, ensuring that the Consignee remits the Net Proceeds of every sale within a strictly defined window.
Net Proceeds and the Right to Audit
Payment Terms should define exactly how the Consignment Commission is calculated and when the Net Proceeds are due. To prevent the misappropriation of funds, we include a Right to Audit clause that allows the Consignor to inspect the Consignee sales records and physical inventory without prior notice. This level of oversight serves as a powerful deterrent against off-the-books sales and ensures that the Consignor receives every dollar of the contracted value.
7. Why Sjkp Llp Is the Authority in Commercial Consignment
The drafting and enforcement of a Consignment Agreement is a high-stakes process that requires a level of tactical expertise found only at the highest tiers of the profession.
At SJKP LLP, we recognize that a consignment is not just a sales agreement; it is a complex bailment that carries significant perfection and insolvency risks. Our firm approaches consignment matters with a singular focus on the rigorous protection of our clients' legal and commercial interests. We do not accept the standard industry form at face value. Instead, we deploy a sophisticated team of commercial strategists to methodically challenge risk imbalances and secure the statutory protections our clients deserve.
We recognize that the window for action in inventory management is exceptionally narrow. The moment a Consignee creditworthiness is questioned or a shipment is delayed, the clock begins to tick on your asset recovery. SJKP LLP provides the decisive legal intervention necessary to manage the momentum of commercial risks and reach a strategic resolution. We have mastered the complexities of the Uniform Commercial Code and the procedural intricacies of the federal and state courts, allowing us to build strategically superior frameworks that are as legally sound as they are strategically dominant. SJKP LLP stands as the formidable barrier between your institutional wealth and the unpredictable risks of the retail and distribution industries.
24 Dec, 2025
