practices
Experts in various fields find solutions for customers. We provide customized solutions based on a thoroughly analyzed litigation database.
New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Legal Remedies and Claim Procedures
Construction payment disputes can cause significant financial hardship. If you've completed a construction project in New York and still haven’t received payment despite a signed agreement, several legal options are available to recover the owed amount.
contents
1. New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: What It Means
Failure to pay for construction services—despite a valid contract—is considered payment noncompliance under New York law. These disputes typically arise when a property owner, developer, or general contractor withholds payment after the project is completed, either in full or in part.
New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Notable Public Case
In February 2025, a construction worker was allegedly assaulted by a group who failed to pay for a golf simulator buildout. The contractors had promised payment but lured the worker into a private property where the incident occurred. Police investigations later revealed ties to organized crime. This case illustrates how civil non-payment issues may escalate into criminal matters.
2. New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Legal Recovery Options
Several legal strategies can be employed to recover unpaid construction fees, depending on the situation.
New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Filing a Civil Lawsuit
You may initiate a civil action under the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR). The steps are:
- Draft and file a complaint: Include the contract, invoices, emails, and payment logs.
- Discovery and hearings: Present evidence, cross-examine the opposing party, and argue your position.
- Judgment: The court may issue a payment order. If successful, you can proceed to enforcement.
Be aware that the statute of limitations for such claims is three years (CPLR § 213).
New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Seeking a Default Judgment
For simpler cases, a motion for default judgment or summary judgment may expedite the process if the opposing party fails to respond. You must submit clear evidence and proof of service. This avoids prolonged trial proceedings.
New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Filing for a Mechanic’s Lien
Under the New York Lien Law, contractors and subcontractors may file a mechanic’s lien against the property. This legal claim attaches to the real estate and prevents sale or refinancing until the dispute is resolved.
To be valid:
File within 8 months of project completion (Lien Law § 10).
Serve the property owner properly.
Include an itemized statement of labor and materials provided.
3. New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Post-Judgment Enforcement
Winning a judgment doesn't guarantee payment. You may need to take further legal action to enforce the court’s decision.
New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Enforcing Judgment through Execution
You can initiate wage garnishment, bank account seizure, or property lien using enforcement procedures under CPLR Article 52. Required documents include:
- Original court judgment
- Transcript of judgment filed with county clerk
- Execution form issued by the clerk
New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Reporting Debtors to Credit Agencies
While not mandatory, creditors may report persistent non-payers to credit bureaus or request entry into the County Clerk’s Judgment Docket. This can hinder the debtor’s financial transactions and act as leverage for payment.
4. New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Importance of Legal Representation
Construction law is document-intensive and time-sensitive. An attorney helps by:
- Verifying contract validity
- Ensuring deadlines (e.g., lien filings) are met
- Structuring claims to maximize recovery
Especially for small contractors dealing with larger entities or institutional clients, legal counsel can level the playing field and prevent coercive tactics.
5. New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Legal Tools at a Glance
Here’s a brief comparison of the main legal tools:
| Legal Tool | Description | Time Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Civil Lawsuit | Traditional route via CPLR | 3 years from due date |
| Mechanic’s Lien | Lien on the property via Lien Law | 8 months post-project |
| Judgment Enforcement | Collection via garnishment or seizure | No fixed limit after judgment |
| Default/Summary Judgment | Expedited ruling if defendant is non-responsive | Must comply with service rules |
6. New York Construction Payment Noncompliance: Final Considerations
Delays in action can compromise your ability to recover payment. It's essential to document communications, retain contracts and receipts, and seek legal assistance early. Whether you're a subcontractor, designer, or supplier, New York provides legal recourse for nonpayment—if used correctly and promptly.
The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading or relying on the contents of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm. For advice regarding your specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
