practices
Experts in various fields find solutions for customers. We provide customized solutions based on a thoroughly analyzed litigation database.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense: Legal Requirements, Penalties, and Case Examples
In New York, the criminal evasion offense refers to knowingly assisting a person who has committed a punishable crime to avoid arrest, prosecution, or punishment. Unlike federal terminology such as “harboring a fugitive,” the state-specific term “rendering criminal assistance” applies, as defined under New York Penal Law Article 205.
contents
1. New York Criminal Evasion Offense: Definition and Legal Meaning
The criminal evasion offense arises when a person helps an offender avoid criminal justice procedures such as arrest, investigation, or imprisonment. It requires that the assisted person has committed a crime punishable by more than a fine, typically a misdemeanor or felony.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense and the Concept of Assistance
Under Penal Law §205.50, assistance may include helping the offender hide, providing false information to law enforcement, or misdirecting investigators. Mere passive behavior does not suffice—it must be an affirmative act intended to obstruct justice.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense and Family Exceptions
New York Penal Law §205.50(2) exempts certain family members from prosecution when the assistance is rendered to relatives. However, the exemption applies strictly to immediate family and does not extend to individuals such as unacknowledged children or those in informal domestic partnerships.
2. New York Criminal Evasion Offense: Elements of the Crime
To constitute a criminal evasion offense under New York law, the following legal elements must be satisfied.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense Requires the Existence of a Predicate Crime
The individual being assisted must have committed a crime that is actually punishable by law. If the conduct in question amounts only to a civil infraction or an administrative violation, the offense of criminal evasion does not apply.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense Requires Intentional Conduct
The assistance must be intentional. That is, the aider must know that the person committed a crime and intentionally help them avoid the law. Mistaken or accidental aid—such as unknowingly providing a ride—does not fulfill this criterion.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense Involves Direct or Indirect Aid
The conduct can include both direct support, like offering shelter, and indirect means, like misleading police. What matters is the result: that the offender gains time or space to evade justice due to the aider’s conduct.
3. New York Criminal Evasion Offense: Penalties and Notable Case Law
Criminal evasion offenses are punishable under varying degrees depending on the seriousness of the original crime and the form of assistance.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense Sentencing Guidelines
Under NY Penal Law §205.55 (Hindering Prosecution in the Second Degree), the offense is a Class A misdemeanor punishable by:
- Up to 1 year in jail
- A fine of up to $1,000
If the person being aided committed a felony, the aider may face charges under §205.60 (First Degree), which is a Class E felony, with penalties of:
- Up to 4 years in prison
- Possible probation or conditional discharge
4. New York Criminal Evasion Offense: Key Considerations for Legal Defense
Several nuanced aspects must be reviewed before determining liability under the criminal evasion offense.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense and Familial Immunity Limitations
The law narrowly defines who qualifies for the family-based exception. For example, domestic partners or unrecognized children are not protected, even if emotionally close to the offender.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense and Coercion or Duress
If the individual rendered assistance due to threats or coercion, such as fear for their own safety, the defense of duress may apply. However, clear evidence is required.
New York Criminal Evasion Offense and Mistaken Identity
In cases where someone unknowingly aids an offender, or misidentifies their actions, courts may find insufficient intent to convict. Legal advice is crucial in distinguishing innocent conduct from criminal complicity.
5. New York Criminal Evasion Offense: Summary Table of Offense Levels
| Degree of Offense | Circumstance | Penalty |
|---|---|---|
| Second Degree (§205.55) | Aiding a misdemeanant | Class A misdemeanor (up to 1 year) |
| First Degree (§205.60) | Aiding a felon | Class E felony (up to 4 years) |
The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading or relying on the contents of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm. For advice regarding your specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
