Property Liens: When a Debt Becomes a Legal Claim against Real Estate

A property lien is an in rem right, meaning the right is attached to the property itself rather than just the person who owns it. It transforms a simple monetary debt into a secured interest. If the debt remains unpaid, the lienholder has a legal pathway to seek satisfaction from the proceeds of the property's sale or, in extreme cases, through a forced foreclosure.

Owning a property gives you the right to possess and use it. A lien is a passive interest. A lienholder does not have the right to live in the house or collect rent, but they do have the right to be paid from the equity. In the legal rails of property law, a lien is a burden on the title that must be resolved before the owner can deliver a clean title to a future buyer.

Property liens generally arise from two sources:

• Consensual Liens: 
• These are created by agreement, such as a mortgage. You grant the bank a lien in exchange for the loan.
• Non-Consensual Liens: 
• These are involuntary and are created by operation of law. This includes tax liens or a Judgment Lien resulting from a lost lawsuit.

To create a valid property lien through the court system, a creditor must first obtain a final judgment. Once the judgment is entered, it must be perfected by recording an abstract or a certified copy of the judgment in the county recorder's office where the real estate is located. If the creditor fails to record the document correctly, the lien may not attach to the property at all.

A Judgment Lien is a frequent tool for enforcement. It effectively freezes the owner's ability to pull cash out of the home through a refinance. A Mechanic’s Lien is uniquely powerful because it can sometimes leapfrog other creditors in priority if the work improved the property's value, though this varies strictly by state law.

When an owner attempts to sell or refinance, a Title Search will be conducted. If property liens appear, the title insurance company will refuse to issue a policy unless the liens are paid off at closing. This means the creditor gets paid directly from the escrow funds before the owner receives a single dollar.

In the event of a sale or foreclosure, there is rarely enough money for everyone. The law uses a First in Time, First in Right rule to determine Lien Priority.

• First Priority: Usually the primary mortgage or property taxes.
• Subsequent Priority: Other property liens are paid in the order they were recorded.

A property lien can be challenged if the creditor failed to follow procedural rules. This includes failing to provide the owner with a notice of intent to lien or recording the lien in the wrong county. If a Mechanic’s Lien is filed past the statutory deadline, which is often 90 days after work is completed, it is voidable and can be removed through a quiet title action.

The most straightforward way to remove a lien is through a Lien Release after the debt is paid. Additionally, most property liens have an expiration date. For example, a Judgment Lien in many states expires after 10 years unless it is formally renewed. If a creditor forgets to renew, the lien disappears and the title is cleared by default.

Before a creditor files a lien, they must ensure they have the legal right to do so. Filing a Wrongful Lien or an Exaggerated Lien can lead to significant liability, including statutory penalties and the requirement to pay the owner's attorney fees.

Before an owner challenges a lien, a comprehensive Title Search is required to see the full landscape of the property's encumbrances. Challenging one lien while three others remain may not achieve the goal of a clear title. We perform a forensic audit of the title to identify the most efficient sequence for clearing the record.