1. Civil Lawyer NYC New York Case Background
Shopping Center Expansion and Tenant Opposition
The dispute arose after a shopping center owner began a planned expansion and renovation of the premises.
While one tenant was directly involved in the expansion, two other tenants objected to the construction activities.
They alleged that dust, noise, and debris from the renovation interfered with their businesses.
Civil Lawyer NYC identified that these objections quickly escalated into claims far exceeding any actual disruption.
2. Civil Lawyer NYC New York Claims Asserted by Tenants
Allegations of Lost Profits and Lease Breach
One tenant asserted claims for hundreds of thousands of dollars, while the other sought approximately four million dollars in damages.
Both alleged that the expansion breached their leases and interfered with their business operations.
Despite these claims, both tenants ceased paying rent during the litigation.
Eventually, each tenant vacated the shopping center while continuing to pursue damages.
3. Civil Lawyer NYC New York Litigation Strategy
Lease-Based Defenses and Counterclaims
Civil Lawyer NYC asserted counterclaims seeking unpaid rent and possession of the premises.
At the same time, motions for summary judgment were filed to dismiss the tenants’ claims in their entirety.
The motions relied on express lease provisions that barred recovery for consequential damages, lost profits, and construction-related interference.
Civil Lawyer NYC demonstrated that the tenants had contractually waived the very damages they were seeking.
4. Civil Lawyer NYC New York Court Decision and Outcome
Dismissal of Claims and Favorable Settlements
The court granted summary judgment dismissing all claims asserted against the landlord.
It further directed the parties to appear for settlement proceedings on the landlord’s counterclaims.
As a result, Civil Lawyer NYC secured six-figure settlements in favor of the landlord for unpaid rent.
In total, potential exposure exceeding four million dollars was transformed into recoveries for the client.
At SJKP, our litigation team regularly serves as a Civil Lawyer NYC for commercial landlords, tenants, and property owners navigating complex lease disputes.
We assist clients with lease enforcement, construction-related claims, rent recovery, and summary judgment motions under New York law.
If you are facing high-stakes commercial litigation involving landlord-tenant disputes, contact SJKP to consult with a Civil Lawyer NYC and protect your interests.
26 Jan, 2026
