1. Tenants Rights Lawyers in NYC Case Background
Tenants rights lawyers NYC often see disputes arise at the end of long term residential leases.
This matter involved a high value condominium lease in Manhattan and a substantial security deposit. The dispute centered on a refusal to return funds after the lease expired.
Expired Lease and Withheld Deposit
A tenant entered into a four year residential lease for a condominium unit in Midtown Manhattan beginning in May 2020 and ending in May 2024.
At the start of the tenancy, the tenant paid a security deposit of five hundred thousand dollars in compliance with the lease agreement.
As the lease term approached its conclusion, the tenant provided proper notice of non renewal and coordinated a move out inspection.
The apartment was surrendered in good condition, and the keys were returned to the landlord.
Despite this, the landlord failed to return the deposit within the timeframe required under New York law and stopped responding to written communications.
Failed Informal Resolution Efforts
Before filing suit, the tenant sent multiple written demands requesting the return of the security deposit.
These communications were delivered by certified mail and electronic message to create a clear record.
The landlord did not provide an itemized statement of damages and did not assert any lawful basis for retaining the funds.
When informal resolution failed, the tenant sought guidance from tenants rights lawyers NYC to evaluate litigation options and enforce statutory protections.
2. Tenants Rights Lawyers in NYC Legal Strategy and Evidence
Tenants rights lawyers NYC approach deposit disputes with a structured evidentiary strategy.
A successful claim requires clear proof of the lease terms, payment history, and compliance with move out obligations.
Careful documentation often determines the outcome.
Documentation and Statutory Compliance
The legal team assembled the signed lease agreement, proof of the wire transfer for the security deposit, renewal documents, and written notice of lease termination.
Photographs and inspection records documented the condition of the apartment at move out.
Under New York General Obligations Law, residential landlords must return the security deposit within fourteen days after the tenant vacates, along with an itemized statement of any lawful deductions.
Failure to comply can result in liability for the full deposit and, in certain circumstances, additional damages.
The landlord’s silence and lack of itemization strengthened the tenant’s position.
Litigation and Court Proceedings
After confirming statutory violations, counsel filed a complaint in New York Supreme Court seeking the return of the full security deposit.
The claim alleged breach of contract and violation of statutory deposit return requirements.
During the proceedings, the landlord attempted to argue unspecified property damage. However, no contemporaneous inspection report or repair invoices were produced.
The court found that the landlord failed to meet the legal burden required to justify withholding any portion of the deposit.
3. Tenants Rights Lawyers in NYC Full Deposit Recovery Outcome
Tenants rights lawyers NYC focus on achieving complete financial restoration for clients.
In this matter, the court issued a judgment directing the landlord to return the entire five hundred thousand dollar security deposit.
The ruling reaffirmed that landlords must strictly comply with deposit handling rules in New York City.
Court Ordered Return of Funds
The court concluded that the tenant had fulfilled all lease obligations and properly surrendered possession of the premises.
The landlord’s failure to provide an itemized deduction statement within the statutory period was a decisive factor.
As a result, judgment was entered for the tenant in the full amount of the deposit.
The decision underscored that even in high value Manhattan leases, landlords remain bound by the same statutory safeguards that protect all residential tenants.
Legal Guidance for NYC Tenants
Security deposit disputes can escalate quickly, particularly when large sums are involved.
Early legal intervention often preserves leverage and prevents prolonged financial loss.
Tenants rights lawyers NYC can assist with formal demand letters, negotiation, and court litigation when necessary.
Our firm evaluates lease language, statutory compliance, and evidentiary strength to pursue full recovery where a landlord acts unlawfully.
If you are facing a withheld security deposit in New York City, our team can assess your case and develop a strategy tailored to your circumstances.
13 Feb, 2026
